SUNDAY MUSINGS - Weird Worlds and How We Write Them

We, as fans of the RPG genre share a common sickness. Give any of us a perfectly serviceable fictional kingdom, a handful of interesting characters and a perfectly reasonable excuse for a bit of adventure, and before long they'll be worrying about the tax arrangements of the local baron, the precise number of days in the agricultural calendar, and whether the people who live in the northern mountains have a different word for cheese. It is, of course, entirely unnecessary. Nobody has ever stopped reading a fantasy novel because the author failed to explain the municipal drainage arrangements of a dwarven settlement. But, among that trivia lies something rather wonderful about the lengths to which we will go to make an imaginary place feel as though it has always been there.

Worldbuilding is often treated as a sort of preparatory exercise, a great heap of maps, histories, family trees and geographical peculiarities assembled before the actual business of telling a story can begin. It is the scaffolding, the background, the stuff that gets in the way of the interesting bits. And yet, when it works, it is often the very thing that makes those interesting bits interesting in the first place. A battle is more than a collection of people hitting one another with increasingly expensive weapons if we understand what the land means to them. A ruined castle is more than a collection of convenient walls if we know who built it, who lived there, and why the locals refuse to go anywhere near the old well. Context is a marvellous thing. It turns a collection of fictional events into somewhere we might actually want to spend our time.

This is something tabletop gaming stumbled into rather wonderfully, largely because it had no choice. The early Dungeons & Dragons campaigns of Dave Arneson and Gary Gygax were not initially designed as beautifully presented fantasy worlds for public consumption. Blackmoor and Greyhawk grew out of games being played, with players wandering off in unexpected directions, making enemies, acquiring property and generally behaving in ways that no sensible author would permit their protagonists to do. The setting had to accommodate them. It needed somewhere for the characters to go, someone for them to annoy, and, eventually, a reason why the local population hadn't already packed up and moved somewhere less heavily populated by adventurers.

That distinction matters. A novelist can decide where the story goes, and the world can be arranged accordingly. A gamesmaster has rather less control over proceedings once the players have decided that the mysterious old woman is clearly hiding something, the king is probably a fraud, and the abandoned watchtower would make an excellent place to store seventeen stolen pigs. The world has to exist beyond the immediate needs of the plot, because the players are perfectly capable of ignoring the plot altogether. Indeed, they may consider this to be the principal attraction.

Terry Pratchett understood this rather well with Discworld. It is tempting to imagine a world like that being assembled from the ground up, with every country, custom and peculiar institution carefully documented before the first book was written. Pratchett's approach was rather more organic. The stories created the world, and the world then acquired a life of its own, with the important proviso that it had to obey the rules established along the way. Ankh-Morpork is perhaps the best example. It is not simply a convenient location in which to deposit a collection of characters; it is a character in its own right, a great, filthy, argumentative organism with its own industries, politics, social arrangements and inexplicable smells. Things happen there whether or not the reader is watching. Somewhere, presumably, somebody is still making sausages, emptying the rubbish and having a thoroughly miserable time at the Department of Guild Licensing.

That is one of the great pleasures of Discworld. The city feels as though it continues to operate when the book is closed. There are people who have absolutely nothing to do with the plot, who will never meet the protagonist, and who are nevertheless getting on with their lives. Pratchett once described how mapping Ankh-Morpork gave him ideas, because the city had to function as a place rather than merely provide a backdrop for the next adventure. Its industries, streets and ordinary inhabitants existed whether or not they happened to be useful to the story. The world was not waiting for the plot to happen. The plot was merely one of the things happening in it.[1]

Warhammer Fantasy Battle took a rather different route, but its Old World demonstrates much the same principle. The setting didn't arrive fully formed, complete with a comprehensive atlas and several thousand years of carefully indexed political history. The first edition was still finding its feet, with a rather broad assortment of fantasy influences, historical miniatures and ideas that had not yet settled into a recognisable world. The second edition's Battle Bestiary gave us the first appearance of the Known World map and timeline, establishing a geographical and historical framework that could be expanded. It was a beginning, rather than the finished article.

The campaign supplements that followed began to give the setting its character in rather more localised ways. Terror of the Lichemaster, Bloodbath at Orc's Drift and The Tragedy of McDeath were not simply excuses to put miniatures on a table and see how many could be removed before teatime. They offered particular places, particular conflicts and little glimpses of a wider world. Their names alone tell you something about the sort of fantasy being assembled: a little folklore, a little Shakespeare, a little historical adventure, and a great deal of unpleasantness involving the dead. The world was being built through the things people could actually play.

Then came Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay in 1986, which helped take the Old World beyond the battlefield and into the lives of the people unfortunate enough to inhabit it. Suddenly, the Empire wasn't simply a place for armies to march across. It was somewhere a rat catcher might earn a living, a coach might get stuck in the mud, a merchant might be robbed, and a village might have a very serious problem with the local priest. The world acquired a much more immediate sense of scale. The important question was no longer simply where the armies were going, but what it might be like to live in the places they were passing through.

Rick Priestley has spoken about developing the Old World from the relatively brief outline in the second edition, drawing on the geography and atmosphere of Central Europe, the Brothers Grimm and the haunted forests of Transylvania. He also describes digging into books on medieval and early modern society to work out the practicalities of the setting: how long journeys would take, how roads and waterways connected settlements, where coach inns and livery would fit into the picture. Marienburg, for example, was conceived as a neighbour to the Empire, with the mercantile and maritime character of the Low Countries and Amsterdam.[2] These are the sorts of details that don't necessarily make it into a battle report, but they make an enormous difference to the world surrounding it. A city is a more convincing place when there is a reason for its existence beyond providing a suitable location for a large metal monster to knock over a tower.

The third edition and the publications that surrounded it continued to build on those foundations. Warhammer Armies gave the factions a more developed identity, while Realm of Chaos: Slaves to Darkness and The Lost and the Damned expanded the mythology and cosmology of the setting in extraordinary directions. The gods, their followers, their rivalries and their histories became part of a much larger picture. Even the setting's mythology was not entirely the product of one carefully planned master document. Rick Priestley has noted that some of the gods appearing in the early Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay material came from the Kaleb Daark comic strip by John Wagner and Alan Grant, published in the Journals and Compendia. Malal and Arianka wandered in from the pages of a comic and briefly found themselves part of the wider mythology, before the rather less fantastical business of intellectual property disputes intervened.[3] It is difficult to imagine a more Warhammer way for a pantheon to develop.

The Old World was, in other words, an accumulation of ideas. Rules writers, miniature designers, illustrators, comic writers and roleplaying authors all contributed to its character, sometimes in ways that were not necessarily planned from the beginning. It developed a history because people kept finding reasons to give it one. And what a world it became: muddy roads, suspicious inns, decaying aristocracy, religious fanaticism and the ever-present possibility that the local village might be swallowed by something with too many teeth. Its various cultures drew on recognisable European history and folklore, but were pushed through the particular filter of Warhammer's rather unhealthy imagination. The Empire was not simply Germany with some wizards added; it was a collection of competing provinces, old grudges, strange traditions and political arrangements that made it feel as though it had accumulated its history rather than been invented for the convenience of a rulebook. The fact that it was also a place where a man might be eaten by a giant rat while travelling to buy turnips was merely an added attraction.

This is where the little details become so important. Not necessarily the grand histories or the elaborate genealogies, but the things that give a place its texture. The dwarfs who wear iron rings in their beards might have a tradition associated with them, or perhaps the rings are awarded for a particular achievement. A coastal village might celebrate the arrival of its third moon with the Seastone Festival, during which everyone is expected to leave a small offering on the beach. Somewhere in the countryside, Aunt Miri's cousin grows saffron, and the locals insist that it is the finest in the province, despite the fact that nobody outside the village has ever heard of it. None of these things need to be important. In fact, they are often more effective when they aren't.

The trick is that the details should feel as though they belong together. A custom should tell us something about the people who practise it, the environment in which they live, or the history they have inherited. A people who live beneath the mountains might have an entirely different relationship with daylight, time and the changing seasons from those who live on the plains. Their food, architecture, religious practices and social arrangements might all reflect that difference. You don't need to explain every consequence, but the suggestion that those consequences exist is enough to make the place feel real. A list of unusual facts is still only a list of unusual facts. A world begins to emerge when those facts start talking to one another.

J.R.R. Tolkien's idea of the Secondary World is often brought into these discussions, and quite rightly. In his essay On Fairy-Stories, he describes the creation of a world in which the reader can believe while they are within it. The important part is not simply that the world contains dragons, elves or an inconvenient number of invented languages, but that it possesses its own internal truth. Tolkien was unusually well equipped for this sort of work, having spent much of his academic life studying language, mythology and the histories of words. Middle-earth was not just a stage on which the stories took place; its languages, peoples and histories were deeply connected, often in ways that the reader would never need to understand in order to enjoy the story. There is a considerable amount of scholarship lurking beneath those hairy feet.

Of course, this does not mean that every fantasy setting needs to be accompanied by a twelve-volume history and a linguistic appendix. There is a point at which the author needs to put down the family tree and allow the characters to get on with things. The reader does not need to know the precise succession of every minor duke in the Kingdom of Whatever, unless one of those dukes has recently murdered somebody or is about to inherit a particularly troublesome hat. What matters is that the creator knows enough to make the world feel consistent, and that the details which do reach the audience suggest a much larger place beyond them.

This is especially true when the world is being explored by players rather than simply read about. A player might never care about the history of a particular village until they discover that the old woman who runs the bakery was once married to the man whose tomb they have just robbed. Suddenly, the village has a past, the tomb has a consequence, and the bakery has become a rather uncomfortable place to visit. The players begin to make connections of their own, and those connections become part of the setting. The gamesmaster may have spent an entire evening inventing a local harvest festival, only for the players to spend the session attempting to steal the ceremonial turnip. This is not a failure of worldbuilding. It is, in many ways, the whole point.

There is also something rather lovely about the way these worlds become shared possessions. The setting might begin as a collection of notes in somebody's exercise book, a map with a few names written around the edges, or a battered rulebook full of questionable illustrations. But once other people have played in it, argued over it, made friends in it, lost characters in it and spent an unreasonable amount of time discussing the political implications of a fictional succession crisis, it becomes something more. The world accumulates memories. It belongs, at least in part, to the people who have experienced it.

Perhaps that is why worldbuilding can be so difficult to explain to anyone who doesn't share the enthusiasm. It is not always about producing something that will be used. Sometimes it is about knowing that it exists. There is a peculiar satisfaction in knowing what happens to the moon-wives before the harvest cull, even if no character ever asks. There is pleasure in a map containing a village that will never appear in a story, or in a history that explains why two neighbouring towns refuse to trade with one another. It is creative work without an immediate practical purpose, which is perhaps why it is so easily dismissed as indulgence. But then, most of the things we enjoy are rather indulgent. Nobody needs a collection of tiny plastic soldiers, either, and yet here we are.

The danger, if there is one, is in mistaking the amount of work for the quality of the result. A world does not become more convincing simply because it has more names, more dates or more pages of notes. It becomes convincing when the things we are shown feel as though they have a reason to exist, and when those things imply a life beyond the immediate story. We don't need to know everything about a place. We just need to believe that there is more to know.

And if that means spending an afternoon deciding what the people of a remote fishing village do with their dead, or whether the local lord's grandfather was responsible for the annual shortage of turnips, then so be it. There are worse ways to spend an afternoon. There are certainly worse things to put in a notebook. Just don't be surprised when the players decide that the turnips are the most important part of the entire campaign.

Footnotes

[1] Pratchett discussed the organic development of Discworld and the importance of Ankh-Morpork as a character in its own right in interviews, including one published in Weird Tales. The city is, in many respects, the most industrious character in the series. It just happens to employ a great many people who would rather not be there.

[2] Rick Priestley discussed the development of the Old World in an interview with Awesome Lies (2024). His comments on travel, roads, waterways, coach inns and Marienburg are particularly revealing. The setting's geography was not simply a matter of drawing a map and filling the gaps with monsters.

[3] The Kaleb Daark strip appeared in Warhammer publications including the Journals and Compendia. Priestley recalled that the gods Malal and Arianka were among the elements introduced through the strip, rather than his original Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay draft. Malal's later disappearance is a rather good example of how real-world publishing complications can become part of a fictional world's history.

[4] Tolkien's On Fairy-Stories began as the Andrew Lang Lecture in 1939 and was published in revised form in 1947. It is a rather more interesting discussion of fantasy than the usual internet quotation-card version might suggest.

[5] Aunt Miri is fictional. Any resemblance to actual saffron growers, living or dead, is entirely coincidental. If she does exist, I would like to know where she gets her saffron.

[6] There is no such thing as an inconsequential detail once a player has decided to spend four hours investigating it.

Next
Next

OLD WORLD ORDER - THE CHAOS DWARVES